If I wrote amazing material, could I change your preference to genre?

Now I have a genre that I like to write about and most likely will be my first novel, as I have shared an exerpt on here already. BUT, it would be a milestone to appeal to EVERY reader, now I know this is a HUGE leap, but hey; everyone has dreams right? So if you like to read the Crime, murder books, could I get you to read a Non-fiction/ psychological thriller? Or maybe the other way around. Just need those thrown-out-there-ideas. Mucho Thanks.